Best Practices for Interviewing


Many factors influence what your hiring and interview process will look like, including your company type and size, your personal interviewing style and the position in question. Regardless, there are some best practices that generally apply to most interviews. Below are suggestions to help facilitate an efficient interview process.

Before the Interview

Preparation is key:

  • Review the job description and the candidate’s resume, application and any other pertinent information before the interview.
  • Have a standard list of questions and method of evaluation.
  • If you’re the hiring manager but don’t work closely with the job or aren’t familiar with the skills required for the open position, talk to others on the team who understand the day-to-day process and needs for the role to gain better insight before interviewing.

During the Interview

Don’t let nerves take over the interview; plan how you will conduct the interview and be aware of your own role in the interview conversation:

  • Start with small talk, but don’t let chattiness (especially nervous chatter) distract from the goal of the interview.
  • Have an awareness of your own body language. If you’re new to interviewing, you’re probably nervous about the interview, too. Make sure you don’t inadvertently send nonverbal messages that you’re angry or closed down during the interview conversation.
  • Take notes; writing notes verbatim can help you remember better later. However, do not mark down the race, gender, etc., of a candidate, as these notes could be used against you in the event that you don’t hire a candidate and are later charged with discrimination.
  • Make sure to listen to the interviewee’s full answer, without interrupting. Use follow-up questions and silence to get more information from candidates.
  • Consider touring the work area with the candidate. You can observe the interviewee’s reaction to the workplace (e.g., a disappointed look at your open office space), and a tour helps the candidate assess how well he or she sees himself working for your company.
  • Close the interview by asking for questions, then tasking the candidate if he or she is interested in the position now that he or she has learned more about the job and company during the interview. You may learn even more about a candidate and his or her fir for the role based on the questions he or she asks of you.

After the Interview

You likely won’t have an instant answer—and certainly shouldn’t give one—when you part ways with the interviewee. Good follow-up practices will help you make the best hiring decision and keep the candidate informed of what is happening:

  • Ask the receptionist and others who interacted with the candidate “unofficially” for their opinions—some individuals act very differently when they don’t think they’re being watched or evaluated.
  • Follow up with your top candidates by conducting reference checks. Although references will often only confirm employment or the completion of a degree, sometimes you can gain good insight about a candidate.
  • Follow up with the candidate, whether or not you decide to hire him or her


More Posts

Updated list of states that require pay disclosure

A new front has emerged in state and local governments’ attempts to address pay inequity. Once an addendum to broader laws restricting the ability of employers to ask about pay during the hiring process, pay disclosure requirements have now become full-fledged, targeted pieces of legislation in a growing number of jurisdictions. Keep reading Article

Why Health Savings Accounts (and HDHPs) Are Still A Good Idea

Health Savings Accounts (HSA) has been around for many years. The combination of HDHP (high deductible health care plan) and a HSA is a great way of helping keep the rising cost of health insurance down at least a little bit. While the combination is not the health insurance premium savior that it once was,

7 HR Challenges Facing Business Owners

2020 has certainly gotten off to a rocky start. Managing human resources in a small or medium-size business is always demanding, but this year employers grapple with challenges many have never confronted before. Here are the top HR hurdles facing employers, along with tips and tactics to keep operations steady even as the world around

Former Indeed employee alleges assault, ‘frat culture’ in sex discrimination suit

A former account executive at Indeed alleged in a lawsuit filed May 18 that the company engaged in gender discrimination by failing to address a sexual assault allegation and allegedly refusing to promote her based on her complaint (Gilbert v. Indeed, Inc., et al., No. 20-CV-03826 (S.D.N.Y. May 18, 2020)).

Send Us A Message